Nectar
Store-bought vs homemade hummingbird nectar
One of these costs about four cents a fill. The other has a supply chain. They are, chemically, nearly the same liquid.
We earn a commission on purchases made through our links, at no extra cost to you. We don’t accept free products or paid placements. Full disclosure.
Make it yourself. Four parts water to one part plain white sugar costs pennies a fill, takes four minutes, and — crucially — you know exactly what is in it, which matters because plenty of commercial nectar still contains red dye that Audubon calls unnecessary and possibly harmful. Commercial nectar earns its place in two cases: convenience while traveling, and concentrate for someone who genuinely cannot manage the boil-and-cool routine.
What we recommend here
| # | Product | Best for | Score | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | No product photo yet Hummingbird Feeder Brush Kit (3-piece) The recurring cost is cleaning, not sugar | What homemade actually needs | 8.4 out of 10 | |
| 2 | No product photo yet Aspects HummZinger HighView 12 oz Two-part saucer, so refilling is not a chore | The feeder that makes homemade easy | 9.0 out of 10 | |
| 3 | No product photo yet First Nature 3051 16 oz Wide-mouth reservoir suits First Nature's own concentrate | Mixes concentrate in the reservoir | 8.6 out of 10 |
Scores are our own editorial ratings from the criteria on our methodology page. They are not customer ratings and they are not test results.
What is actually in each
Homemade nectar is sucrose dissolved in water at roughly 20 percent, which is approximately the concentration of the flower nectar hummingbirds evolved on.
Commercial nectar is sucrose dissolved in water, plus — depending on the product — preservatives, and often red dye. Some brands now sell dye-free versions specifically because of the concern about coloring.
The chemistry is not the differentiator. The differentiators are cost, control and convenience.
Cost
A cup of sugar makes about 32 oz of nectar. That is several feeder-fills from a fraction of a bag of sugar. Commercial ready-to-use nectar is mostly water you are paying to ship; concentrate is better value but still a large multiple of the homemade cost.
Over a season, with a feeder emptied and refilled every three to five days, the difference is real money for the same liquid.
Control — the argument that actually decides it
When you mix it yourself you know there is no dye, no honey, no unrefined sugar and no additive of any kind. That is not a hypothetical benefit: red dye is still on plenty of shelves, and Audubon’s position on it is clear. See is red dye bad for hummingbirds.
If you do buy commercial, buy the clear kind and read the label rather than the front of the box.
When store-bought genuinely makes sense
- Travel, or a second home. A jug of concentrate in the car is simpler than boiling water somewhere you do not have a kitchen.
- Mobility or convenience constraints. If boiling and cooling a pan is genuinely difficult, a clear concentrate you dilute cold is far better than a feeder that does not get refilled. The First Nature reservoir is designed for mixing their concentrate directly in the feeder, which removes a step entirely.
Both of those are real. Neither is a reason for most people to buy nectar most of the time.
The thing neither option solves
Commercial nectar sometimes markets itself on lasting longer in the feeder. Treat that claim carefully. What spoils nectar outdoors is heat and contamination, and a preservative does not change the schedule Cornell recommends: change sugar water every three to five days, and daily in very hot weather.
Nothing you pour in buys you a longer interval. The interval is set by the weather, and the only real lever you have is a feeder that is fast enough to clean that you keep doing it — which is why we score cleaning access on every pick on the site.
Recommended for this
What we’d buy
1. What homemade actually needs
Hummingbird Feeder Brush Kit (3-piece)
A bottle brush, a socket brush and a thin port brush. The port brush is the one that matters — it is the only thing that reaches inside a flower port, and a flower port is where mold starts.
photo yet
- Bottle brush
- Typically 13.5" long, 1.5" bristle diameter
- Socket brush
- Typically 8" long, 1" bristle diameter
- Port brush
- Typically 8.25" long, sized for feeding ports
- Bristles
- Nylon — non-scratching on glass and plastic
Our score: 8.4/10 — an editorial rating, not a customer rating or a test result.
Cleaning access
Rinse the brushes when you rinse the feeder and stand them up to dry. A brush stored wet in a drawer grows its own problem.
What works
- The port brush reaches the one surface a sponge and a stream of water never will
- Nylon bristles will not scratch polycarbonate, which is what makes it cloud
- Cheap enough that there is no argument for not owning one
What doesn’t
- Kit contents vary by seller — check the port brush is actually included
- A 13.5" bottle brush will not reach the bottom of a tall 32 oz reservoir
- Bristles wear out; a splayed brush stops reaching into ports
Specifications from Duncraft — Nectar Brush Set and Blue Bird Landing — Hummingbird Feeder Cleaning Brush 3-Piece Kit. We have not handled this feeder — here is what we did instead.
2. The feeder that makes homemade easy
Aspects HummZinger HighView 12 oz
A four-port saucer feeder with the ant moat built into the lid and a cover that lifts straight off — the shortest path from hanging it up to washing it out.
photo yet
- Type
- Saucer (dish)
- Capacity
- 12 oz
- Feeding ports
- 4
- Material
- Polycarbonate, metal hanger
- Dimensions
- 7.75" x 7.75" x 1.75"
- Ant moat
- Built in
- Perch
- Raised wraparound perch
- Mounting
- Hang or post mount
Our score: 9.0/10 — an editorial rating, not a customer rating or a test result.
Cleaning access
Two parts. The cover lifts off the base with no tools and no threads to cross, and the whole dish is one open bowl — a two-minute wash with a brush and hot water, which is exactly the cadence a nectar feeder needs. The moat is part of the lid, so there is no separate accessory to lose or forget to refill.
What works
- Saucer design puts nectar below the ports, so it does not drip as the air inside warms
- Ant moat is integral to the lid rather than a separate hanging accessory
- Opens to a single shallow bowl — the easiest shape in the category to scrub
- Raised ports shed rain, which keeps the nectar from being diluted
What doesn’t
- 12 oz is small for a busy yard
- Polycarbonate clouds over several seasons in a way glass does not
- No bee-excluding port tips fitted — that is the Ultra's feature, not the HighView's
Specifications from Duncraft — Aspects High View HummZinger and Amazon — Aspects HummZinger HighView 12 oz. We have not handled this feeder — here is what we did instead.
3. Mixes concentrate in the reservoir
First Nature 3051 16 oz
Ten ports, a wide-mouth reservoir and a base that twists into two pieces — the cheapest feeder in the category that is genuinely easy to clean, which is the only reason it is here.
photo yet
- Type
- Inverted bottle
- Capacity
- 16 oz
- Feeding ports
- 10
- Material
- Plastic
- Base
- Patented two-part base, twists apart
- Reservoir
- Wide-mouth
- Ant moat
- Built into the base
- Dishwasher
- Not dishwasher safe — warm soapy water
Our score: 8.6/10 — an editorial rating, not a customer rating or a test result.
Cleaning access
Better than the price suggests. The reservoir mouth is wide enough to take a bottle brush without contortions, and the base twists into two pieces so you can reach the underside of the ports — the spot that grows mold first on a cheap bottle feeder. First Nature specifies warm soapy water, not the dishwasher.
What works
- Wide-mouth reservoir takes a standard bottle brush, unlike most budget bottle feeders
- Two-part base opens up the port undersides, which is where mold starts
- Ten ports and an integrated ant moat at the bottom of the category's price range
What doesn’t
- It is an inverted bottle, so it can drip as trapped air warms and pushes nectar out
- Not dishwasher safe, and the thin plastic would not enjoy a hot wash anyway
- Fill all 16 oz in a quiet yard and you will pour most of it away
Specifications from Amazon — First Nature 10-Port Hummingbird Feeder 3051, 16 oz and Oak Ridge Stores — First Nature FN3051. We have not handled this feeder — here is what we did instead.
Common questions
Frequently asked
Is store-bought hummingbird nectar bad?
Not inherently — plain clear commercial nectar is close to the same liquid you would mix at home. The problems are cost and the fact that many products still contain red dye, which Audubon calls unnecessary and possibly harmful.
Does commercial nectar last longer in the feeder?
Not in a way you should rely on. Nectar spoils because of heat and contamination outdoors, and the change schedule stays the same: every three to five days, daily in very hot weather.
Is homemade hummingbird nectar cheaper?
Dramatically. A cup of sugar makes roughly 32 oz. Ready-to-use commercial nectar is mostly water you are paying to have shipped.
Sources
Where this came from
Read next
Related reading
By Scooter M.
an enthusiast who's genuinely into this. I read the manuals, compile the published specs, and do the math. No lab coat.
Published September 1, 2026